Why the work done is positive when bringing 2 opposite charges together?What is the sign of the work done on the system and by the system?Work done should be positive but coming out negative?Derivation of a work done by forces on chargeWhen is work done on or by something?Need help with signs (+ -) in electric potential work and potential energy problemWhy gravitational potential is negative, as displacement and force are in the same direction?Why is the work done in moving a unit mass from infinity to a point (where gravitational field exists) negative?What is the significance of the sign of work done? Does it affect internal energy also?What is the difference between positive negative potential and positive, negative work done?Why can work done by friction be negative if work is a scalar?

How to become an Editorial board member?

Was murdering a slave illegal in American slavery, and if so, what punishments were given for it?

Axiom of Choice in General Topology

Split date rows by new year

How can I reduce the size of matrix?

Which values for voltage divider

Coloring lines in a graph the same color if they are the same length

Does ls -R make any sense with -d?

Can you "hand off" from Fly to Levitate?

Is a world with one country feeding everyone possible?

Were there any developed countries that became "undeveloped" for reasons other than war?

Why the work done is positive when bringing 2 opposite charges together?

Is being an extrovert a necessary condition to be a manager?

Why is a weak base more able to deprotonate a strong acid than a weak acid?

Island Perimeter

Why did Nick Fury not hesitate in blowing up the plane he thought was carrying a nuke?

Illustrating that universal optimality is stronger than sphere packing

Why is this python script running in background consuming 100 % CPU?

Is there an idiom that means that you are in a very strong negotiation position in a negotiation?

Is ideal gas incompressible?

Is it safe to redirect stdout and stderr to the same file without file descriptor copies?

Existence of a model of ZFC in which the natural numbers are really the natural numbers

Can a UK national work as a paid shop assistant in the USA?

Caught with my phone during an exam



Why the work done is positive when bringing 2 opposite charges together?


What is the sign of the work done on the system and by the system?Work done should be positive but coming out negative?Derivation of a work done by forces on chargeWhen is work done on or by something?Need help with signs (+ -) in electric potential work and potential energy problemWhy gravitational potential is negative, as displacement and force are in the same direction?Why is the work done in moving a unit mass from infinity to a point (where gravitational field exists) negative?What is the significance of the sign of work done? Does it affect internal energy also?What is the difference between positive negative potential and positive, negative work done?Why can work done by friction be negative if work is a scalar?













2












$begingroup$


we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



From mathematical point of view it says the applied force is positive here and the (dr) is negative here.but what's the physical significance of the sign is here?and if so when can we say the applied force is positive or negative(in case of bringing two same charges together)?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$











  • $begingroup$
    $W=vecFcdotDelta vecx$ ... but what is $vecF$? The electrostatic force between the two charges, or the force that is (somehow) pushing the charges?
    $endgroup$
    – garyp
    1 hour ago
















2












$begingroup$


we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



From mathematical point of view it says the applied force is positive here and the (dr) is negative here.but what's the physical significance of the sign is here?and if so when can we say the applied force is positive or negative(in case of bringing two same charges together)?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$











  • $begingroup$
    $W=vecFcdotDelta vecx$ ... but what is $vecF$? The electrostatic force between the two charges, or the force that is (somehow) pushing the charges?
    $endgroup$
    – garyp
    1 hour ago














2












2








2





$begingroup$


we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



From mathematical point of view it says the applied force is positive here and the (dr) is negative here.but what's the physical significance of the sign is here?and if so when can we say the applied force is positive or negative(in case of bringing two same charges together)?










share|cite|improve this question











$endgroup$




we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



From mathematical point of view it says the applied force is positive here and the (dr) is negative here.but what's the physical significance of the sign is here?and if so when can we say the applied force is positive or negative(in case of bringing two same charges together)?







electrostatics work conventions






share|cite|improve this question















share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited 2 hours ago









Qmechanic

109k122051274




109k122051274










asked 2 hours ago









HawkingoHawkingo

897




897











  • $begingroup$
    $W=vecFcdotDelta vecx$ ... but what is $vecF$? The electrostatic force between the two charges, or the force that is (somehow) pushing the charges?
    $endgroup$
    – garyp
    1 hour ago

















  • $begingroup$
    $W=vecFcdotDelta vecx$ ... but what is $vecF$? The electrostatic force between the two charges, or the force that is (somehow) pushing the charges?
    $endgroup$
    – garyp
    1 hour ago
















$begingroup$
$W=vecFcdotDelta vecx$ ... but what is $vecF$? The electrostatic force between the two charges, or the force that is (somehow) pushing the charges?
$endgroup$
– garyp
1 hour ago





$begingroup$
$W=vecFcdotDelta vecx$ ... but what is $vecF$? The electrostatic force between the two charges, or the force that is (somehow) pushing the charges?
$endgroup$
– garyp
1 hour ago











5 Answers
5






active

oldest

votes


















2












$begingroup$

"we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction."



I think you are not considering the displacement as a vector- suppose one is at a position r and moves a unit positive charge towards the other positive charge;
then his differential element is - dr (a decrement in r)
so F.dr the work done
becomes equivalent to - F.dr and the angle between F and dr is pi as they are just opposite to each other.



or say F is radially outward and dr is inward.
thereby the work done



dw = - (F.dr) = - IFI . IdrI .Cos (pi) = |Fdr|
a positive number.



Let us now take situation in which the unit positive charge is moved from r towards a negative charge , then again dr is a decrement in r and its -dr.



the work done will be dw = - F.dr
now F is radially inward and dr is a decrement so the angle between them is zero.



thereby the dw will be -ve. and such negative work is being done by the field rather than the external agency.






share|cite|improve this answer









$endgroup$




















    1












    $begingroup$

    It is a matter of who is doing the work. We are often interested in experiments where the work is done by the experimenter. In the case that you are mentioning, the experimenter has to apply force against the force of repulsion between the particles to bring two positively charged objects at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of the force of the experimenter is the same as the direction of the displacement and therefore the work done is positive. Reverse holds for the oppositely charged particles. The particles are trying to pull each other together and the experimenter has to apply force to keep them at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of force and displacement wrt to the experimenter is opposite.






    share|cite|improve this answer









    $endgroup$




















      1












      $begingroup$

      Remember that work is defined as $W=vecFcdot vecx$ so only the angle between force and displacement matters not the sign convention (in the one-dimensional case). $dr$ is negative means that $r$ is decreasing and the positive direction here is taken in the direction away from the other charge and the work done by an external force is considered so force and displacement are in opposite direction and hence the work done (by external agent) is negative.






      share|cite|improve this answer









      $endgroup$




















        1












        $begingroup$

        In the end this depends on the context. Are you asking "How much work did the system do?" or are you asking "How much work was applied to the system?". The former is really only useful when your system is some kind of motor / energy source, where you are looking at (one form of) energy flowing into a different system. The latter framing is how we usually talk in pure physics considerations. The idea here is that the work should be positive when the energy in the system increases and negative when it decreases.




        Let's adopt the latter convention and apply it to your example: We have one positive charge $A$ "nailed to" the origin of our coordinate system and a negative one, $B$, at infinity. We say that $B$ has the potential energy $E_0 = 0,mathrm J$. Since opposite charges attract, $B$ will naturally fall toward $A$, so its potential energy has to decrease to some negative value $E_1$ when being moved to a new position at a finite distance from $A$. The work you are looking for is just $W = E_1$ here (which is negative).



        Remember that we are only considering transitions between static states of the system here, i.e. no kinetic energies. You could say we want to move $B$ towards $A$ at an infinitely small velocity. In order to do that, we have to work against the charge's natural drive to fall towards $A$, so the force "we" are applying is opposite to the direction of movement.






        share|cite|improve this answer











        $endgroup$




















          0












          $begingroup$

          we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



          What makes you think the work done is negative?



          If the electric field is bringing opposite charges together the electric field is doing positive work on each causing each to lose potential energy and gain kinetic energy. The force the field applies to each charge is in the same direction as their displacement.



          The gravity analogy is the gravitational field doing work on a falling object. The direction of the force of gravity is the same as the displacement and the object loses potential energy and gains an equal amount of kinetic energy.



          On the other hand, if the charges are initially close together and you want to separate them (move them apart), then an external agent is needed to do work positive work to separate them applying a force equal in magnitude to the opposing electrical force (thus moving the charge at constant velocity). However at the same time the external force does positive work on the charges, the electric field does an equal amount of negative work taking the energy away from the charge and storing it as electrical potential energy in the charge/electric field system.



          The gravity analogy is when you apply an upward force equal to gravity to raise an object a height $h$. You (the external agent) does positive work on the object while gravity does an equal amount of negative work (the force of gravity being opposite to the displacement), taking the energy away from the object and storing it as gravitational potential energy of the object/earth system.



          Hope this helps.






          share|cite|improve this answer









          $endgroup$













            Your Answer








            StackExchange.ready(function()
            var channelOptions =
            tags: "".split(" "),
            id: "151"
            ;
            initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

            StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
            // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
            if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
            StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
            createEditor();
            );

            else
            createEditor();

            );

            function createEditor()
            StackExchange.prepareEditor(
            heartbeatType: 'answer',
            autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
            convertImagesToLinks: false,
            noModals: true,
            showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
            reputationToPostImages: null,
            bindNavPrevention: true,
            postfix: "",
            imageUploader:
            brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
            contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
            allowUrls: true
            ,
            noCode: true, onDemand: true,
            discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
            ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
            );



            );













            draft saved

            draft discarded


















            StackExchange.ready(
            function ()
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphysics.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f481126%2fwhy-the-work-done-is-positive-when-bringing-2-opposite-charges-together%23new-answer', 'question_page');

            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown

























            5 Answers
            5






            active

            oldest

            votes








            5 Answers
            5






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            2












            $begingroup$

            "we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction."



            I think you are not considering the displacement as a vector- suppose one is at a position r and moves a unit positive charge towards the other positive charge;
            then his differential element is - dr (a decrement in r)
            so F.dr the work done
            becomes equivalent to - F.dr and the angle between F and dr is pi as they are just opposite to each other.



            or say F is radially outward and dr is inward.
            thereby the work done



            dw = - (F.dr) = - IFI . IdrI .Cos (pi) = |Fdr|
            a positive number.



            Let us now take situation in which the unit positive charge is moved from r towards a negative charge , then again dr is a decrement in r and its -dr.



            the work done will be dw = - F.dr
            now F is radially inward and dr is a decrement so the angle between them is zero.



            thereby the dw will be -ve. and such negative work is being done by the field rather than the external agency.






            share|cite|improve this answer









            $endgroup$

















              2












              $begingroup$

              "we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction."



              I think you are not considering the displacement as a vector- suppose one is at a position r and moves a unit positive charge towards the other positive charge;
              then his differential element is - dr (a decrement in r)
              so F.dr the work done
              becomes equivalent to - F.dr and the angle between F and dr is pi as they are just opposite to each other.



              or say F is radially outward and dr is inward.
              thereby the work done



              dw = - (F.dr) = - IFI . IdrI .Cos (pi) = |Fdr|
              a positive number.



              Let us now take situation in which the unit positive charge is moved from r towards a negative charge , then again dr is a decrement in r and its -dr.



              the work done will be dw = - F.dr
              now F is radially inward and dr is a decrement so the angle between them is zero.



              thereby the dw will be -ve. and such negative work is being done by the field rather than the external agency.






              share|cite|improve this answer









              $endgroup$















                2












                2








                2





                $begingroup$

                "we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction."



                I think you are not considering the displacement as a vector- suppose one is at a position r and moves a unit positive charge towards the other positive charge;
                then his differential element is - dr (a decrement in r)
                so F.dr the work done
                becomes equivalent to - F.dr and the angle between F and dr is pi as they are just opposite to each other.



                or say F is radially outward and dr is inward.
                thereby the work done



                dw = - (F.dr) = - IFI . IdrI .Cos (pi) = |Fdr|
                a positive number.



                Let us now take situation in which the unit positive charge is moved from r towards a negative charge , then again dr is a decrement in r and its -dr.



                the work done will be dw = - F.dr
                now F is radially inward and dr is a decrement so the angle between them is zero.



                thereby the dw will be -ve. and such negative work is being done by the field rather than the external agency.






                share|cite|improve this answer









                $endgroup$



                "we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction."



                I think you are not considering the displacement as a vector- suppose one is at a position r and moves a unit positive charge towards the other positive charge;
                then his differential element is - dr (a decrement in r)
                so F.dr the work done
                becomes equivalent to - F.dr and the angle between F and dr is pi as they are just opposite to each other.



                or say F is radially outward and dr is inward.
                thereby the work done



                dw = - (F.dr) = - IFI . IdrI .Cos (pi) = |Fdr|
                a positive number.



                Let us now take situation in which the unit positive charge is moved from r towards a negative charge , then again dr is a decrement in r and its -dr.



                the work done will be dw = - F.dr
                now F is radially inward and dr is a decrement so the angle between them is zero.



                thereby the dw will be -ve. and such negative work is being done by the field rather than the external agency.







                share|cite|improve this answer












                share|cite|improve this answer



                share|cite|improve this answer










                answered 1 hour ago









                drvrmdrvrm

                1,313614




                1,313614





















                    1












                    $begingroup$

                    It is a matter of who is doing the work. We are often interested in experiments where the work is done by the experimenter. In the case that you are mentioning, the experimenter has to apply force against the force of repulsion between the particles to bring two positively charged objects at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of the force of the experimenter is the same as the direction of the displacement and therefore the work done is positive. Reverse holds for the oppositely charged particles. The particles are trying to pull each other together and the experimenter has to apply force to keep them at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of force and displacement wrt to the experimenter is opposite.






                    share|cite|improve this answer









                    $endgroup$

















                      1












                      $begingroup$

                      It is a matter of who is doing the work. We are often interested in experiments where the work is done by the experimenter. In the case that you are mentioning, the experimenter has to apply force against the force of repulsion between the particles to bring two positively charged objects at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of the force of the experimenter is the same as the direction of the displacement and therefore the work done is positive. Reverse holds for the oppositely charged particles. The particles are trying to pull each other together and the experimenter has to apply force to keep them at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of force and displacement wrt to the experimenter is opposite.






                      share|cite|improve this answer









                      $endgroup$















                        1












                        1








                        1





                        $begingroup$

                        It is a matter of who is doing the work. We are often interested in experiments where the work is done by the experimenter. In the case that you are mentioning, the experimenter has to apply force against the force of repulsion between the particles to bring two positively charged objects at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of the force of the experimenter is the same as the direction of the displacement and therefore the work done is positive. Reverse holds for the oppositely charged particles. The particles are trying to pull each other together and the experimenter has to apply force to keep them at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of force and displacement wrt to the experimenter is opposite.






                        share|cite|improve this answer









                        $endgroup$



                        It is a matter of who is doing the work. We are often interested in experiments where the work is done by the experimenter. In the case that you are mentioning, the experimenter has to apply force against the force of repulsion between the particles to bring two positively charged objects at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of the force of the experimenter is the same as the direction of the displacement and therefore the work done is positive. Reverse holds for the oppositely charged particles. The particles are trying to pull each other together and the experimenter has to apply force to keep them at a finite distance. Therefore the direction of force and displacement wrt to the experimenter is opposite.







                        share|cite|improve this answer












                        share|cite|improve this answer



                        share|cite|improve this answer










                        answered 2 hours ago









                        nGlacTOwnSnGlacTOwnS

                        301112




                        301112





















                            1












                            $begingroup$

                            Remember that work is defined as $W=vecFcdot vecx$ so only the angle between force and displacement matters not the sign convention (in the one-dimensional case). $dr$ is negative means that $r$ is decreasing and the positive direction here is taken in the direction away from the other charge and the work done by an external force is considered so force and displacement are in opposite direction and hence the work done (by external agent) is negative.






                            share|cite|improve this answer









                            $endgroup$

















                              1












                              $begingroup$

                              Remember that work is defined as $W=vecFcdot vecx$ so only the angle between force and displacement matters not the sign convention (in the one-dimensional case). $dr$ is negative means that $r$ is decreasing and the positive direction here is taken in the direction away from the other charge and the work done by an external force is considered so force and displacement are in opposite direction and hence the work done (by external agent) is negative.






                              share|cite|improve this answer









                              $endgroup$















                                1












                                1








                                1





                                $begingroup$

                                Remember that work is defined as $W=vecFcdot vecx$ so only the angle between force and displacement matters not the sign convention (in the one-dimensional case). $dr$ is negative means that $r$ is decreasing and the positive direction here is taken in the direction away from the other charge and the work done by an external force is considered so force and displacement are in opposite direction and hence the work done (by external agent) is negative.






                                share|cite|improve this answer









                                $endgroup$



                                Remember that work is defined as $W=vecFcdot vecx$ so only the angle between force and displacement matters not the sign convention (in the one-dimensional case). $dr$ is negative means that $r$ is decreasing and the positive direction here is taken in the direction away from the other charge and the work done by an external force is considered so force and displacement are in opposite direction and hence the work done (by external agent) is negative.







                                share|cite|improve this answer












                                share|cite|improve this answer



                                share|cite|improve this answer










                                answered 2 hours ago









                                RandomRandom

                                434




                                434





















                                    1












                                    $begingroup$

                                    In the end this depends on the context. Are you asking "How much work did the system do?" or are you asking "How much work was applied to the system?". The former is really only useful when your system is some kind of motor / energy source, where you are looking at (one form of) energy flowing into a different system. The latter framing is how we usually talk in pure physics considerations. The idea here is that the work should be positive when the energy in the system increases and negative when it decreases.




                                    Let's adopt the latter convention and apply it to your example: We have one positive charge $A$ "nailed to" the origin of our coordinate system and a negative one, $B$, at infinity. We say that $B$ has the potential energy $E_0 = 0,mathrm J$. Since opposite charges attract, $B$ will naturally fall toward $A$, so its potential energy has to decrease to some negative value $E_1$ when being moved to a new position at a finite distance from $A$. The work you are looking for is just $W = E_1$ here (which is negative).



                                    Remember that we are only considering transitions between static states of the system here, i.e. no kinetic energies. You could say we want to move $B$ towards $A$ at an infinitely small velocity. In order to do that, we have to work against the charge's natural drive to fall towards $A$, so the force "we" are applying is opposite to the direction of movement.






                                    share|cite|improve this answer











                                    $endgroup$

















                                      1












                                      $begingroup$

                                      In the end this depends on the context. Are you asking "How much work did the system do?" or are you asking "How much work was applied to the system?". The former is really only useful when your system is some kind of motor / energy source, where you are looking at (one form of) energy flowing into a different system. The latter framing is how we usually talk in pure physics considerations. The idea here is that the work should be positive when the energy in the system increases and negative when it decreases.




                                      Let's adopt the latter convention and apply it to your example: We have one positive charge $A$ "nailed to" the origin of our coordinate system and a negative one, $B$, at infinity. We say that $B$ has the potential energy $E_0 = 0,mathrm J$. Since opposite charges attract, $B$ will naturally fall toward $A$, so its potential energy has to decrease to some negative value $E_1$ when being moved to a new position at a finite distance from $A$. The work you are looking for is just $W = E_1$ here (which is negative).



                                      Remember that we are only considering transitions between static states of the system here, i.e. no kinetic energies. You could say we want to move $B$ towards $A$ at an infinitely small velocity. In order to do that, we have to work against the charge's natural drive to fall towards $A$, so the force "we" are applying is opposite to the direction of movement.






                                      share|cite|improve this answer











                                      $endgroup$















                                        1












                                        1








                                        1





                                        $begingroup$

                                        In the end this depends on the context. Are you asking "How much work did the system do?" or are you asking "How much work was applied to the system?". The former is really only useful when your system is some kind of motor / energy source, where you are looking at (one form of) energy flowing into a different system. The latter framing is how we usually talk in pure physics considerations. The idea here is that the work should be positive when the energy in the system increases and negative when it decreases.




                                        Let's adopt the latter convention and apply it to your example: We have one positive charge $A$ "nailed to" the origin of our coordinate system and a negative one, $B$, at infinity. We say that $B$ has the potential energy $E_0 = 0,mathrm J$. Since opposite charges attract, $B$ will naturally fall toward $A$, so its potential energy has to decrease to some negative value $E_1$ when being moved to a new position at a finite distance from $A$. The work you are looking for is just $W = E_1$ here (which is negative).



                                        Remember that we are only considering transitions between static states of the system here, i.e. no kinetic energies. You could say we want to move $B$ towards $A$ at an infinitely small velocity. In order to do that, we have to work against the charge's natural drive to fall towards $A$, so the force "we" are applying is opposite to the direction of movement.






                                        share|cite|improve this answer











                                        $endgroup$



                                        In the end this depends on the context. Are you asking "How much work did the system do?" or are you asking "How much work was applied to the system?". The former is really only useful when your system is some kind of motor / energy source, where you are looking at (one form of) energy flowing into a different system. The latter framing is how we usually talk in pure physics considerations. The idea here is that the work should be positive when the energy in the system increases and negative when it decreases.




                                        Let's adopt the latter convention and apply it to your example: We have one positive charge $A$ "nailed to" the origin of our coordinate system and a negative one, $B$, at infinity. We say that $B$ has the potential energy $E_0 = 0,mathrm J$. Since opposite charges attract, $B$ will naturally fall toward $A$, so its potential energy has to decrease to some negative value $E_1$ when being moved to a new position at a finite distance from $A$. The work you are looking for is just $W = E_1$ here (which is negative).



                                        Remember that we are only considering transitions between static states of the system here, i.e. no kinetic energies. You could say we want to move $B$ towards $A$ at an infinitely small velocity. In order to do that, we have to work against the charge's natural drive to fall towards $A$, so the force "we" are applying is opposite to the direction of movement.







                                        share|cite|improve this answer














                                        share|cite|improve this answer



                                        share|cite|improve this answer








                                        edited 1 hour ago

























                                        answered 1 hour ago









                                        schtandardschtandard

                                        27615




                                        27615





















                                            0












                                            $begingroup$

                                            we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



                                            What makes you think the work done is negative?



                                            If the electric field is bringing opposite charges together the electric field is doing positive work on each causing each to lose potential energy and gain kinetic energy. The force the field applies to each charge is in the same direction as their displacement.



                                            The gravity analogy is the gravitational field doing work on a falling object. The direction of the force of gravity is the same as the displacement and the object loses potential energy and gains an equal amount of kinetic energy.



                                            On the other hand, if the charges are initially close together and you want to separate them (move them apart), then an external agent is needed to do work positive work to separate them applying a force equal in magnitude to the opposing electrical force (thus moving the charge at constant velocity). However at the same time the external force does positive work on the charges, the electric field does an equal amount of negative work taking the energy away from the charge and storing it as electrical potential energy in the charge/electric field system.



                                            The gravity analogy is when you apply an upward force equal to gravity to raise an object a height $h$. You (the external agent) does positive work on the object while gravity does an equal amount of negative work (the force of gravity being opposite to the displacement), taking the energy away from the object and storing it as gravitational potential energy of the object/earth system.



                                            Hope this helps.






                                            share|cite|improve this answer









                                            $endgroup$

















                                              0












                                              $begingroup$

                                              we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



                                              What makes you think the work done is negative?



                                              If the electric field is bringing opposite charges together the electric field is doing positive work on each causing each to lose potential energy and gain kinetic energy. The force the field applies to each charge is in the same direction as their displacement.



                                              The gravity analogy is the gravitational field doing work on a falling object. The direction of the force of gravity is the same as the displacement and the object loses potential energy and gains an equal amount of kinetic energy.



                                              On the other hand, if the charges are initially close together and you want to separate them (move them apart), then an external agent is needed to do work positive work to separate them applying a force equal in magnitude to the opposing electrical force (thus moving the charge at constant velocity). However at the same time the external force does positive work on the charges, the electric field does an equal amount of negative work taking the energy away from the charge and storing it as electrical potential energy in the charge/electric field system.



                                              The gravity analogy is when you apply an upward force equal to gravity to raise an object a height $h$. You (the external agent) does positive work on the object while gravity does an equal amount of negative work (the force of gravity being opposite to the displacement), taking the energy away from the object and storing it as gravitational potential energy of the object/earth system.



                                              Hope this helps.






                                              share|cite|improve this answer









                                              $endgroup$















                                                0












                                                0








                                                0





                                                $begingroup$

                                                we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



                                                What makes you think the work done is negative?



                                                If the electric field is bringing opposite charges together the electric field is doing positive work on each causing each to lose potential energy and gain kinetic energy. The force the field applies to each charge is in the same direction as their displacement.



                                                The gravity analogy is the gravitational field doing work on a falling object. The direction of the force of gravity is the same as the displacement and the object loses potential energy and gains an equal amount of kinetic energy.



                                                On the other hand, if the charges are initially close together and you want to separate them (move them apart), then an external agent is needed to do work positive work to separate them applying a force equal in magnitude to the opposing electrical force (thus moving the charge at constant velocity). However at the same time the external force does positive work on the charges, the electric field does an equal amount of negative work taking the energy away from the charge and storing it as electrical potential energy in the charge/electric field system.



                                                The gravity analogy is when you apply an upward force equal to gravity to raise an object a height $h$. You (the external agent) does positive work on the object while gravity does an equal amount of negative work (the force of gravity being opposite to the displacement), taking the energy away from the object and storing it as gravitational potential energy of the object/earth system.



                                                Hope this helps.






                                                share|cite|improve this answer









                                                $endgroup$



                                                we know that if the applied force is in the direction of the displacement then work done is positive.But in case of bringing 2 opposite charges from infinite to a certain distance,the work done is negative even the force and the displacement of the charge is in the same direction.



                                                What makes you think the work done is negative?



                                                If the electric field is bringing opposite charges together the electric field is doing positive work on each causing each to lose potential energy and gain kinetic energy. The force the field applies to each charge is in the same direction as their displacement.



                                                The gravity analogy is the gravitational field doing work on a falling object. The direction of the force of gravity is the same as the displacement and the object loses potential energy and gains an equal amount of kinetic energy.



                                                On the other hand, if the charges are initially close together and you want to separate them (move them apart), then an external agent is needed to do work positive work to separate them applying a force equal in magnitude to the opposing electrical force (thus moving the charge at constant velocity). However at the same time the external force does positive work on the charges, the electric field does an equal amount of negative work taking the energy away from the charge and storing it as electrical potential energy in the charge/electric field system.



                                                The gravity analogy is when you apply an upward force equal to gravity to raise an object a height $h$. You (the external agent) does positive work on the object while gravity does an equal amount of negative work (the force of gravity being opposite to the displacement), taking the energy away from the object and storing it as gravitational potential energy of the object/earth system.



                                                Hope this helps.







                                                share|cite|improve this answer












                                                share|cite|improve this answer



                                                share|cite|improve this answer










                                                answered 1 hour ago









                                                Bob DBob D

                                                6,5042623




                                                6,5042623



























                                                    draft saved

                                                    draft discarded
















































                                                    Thanks for contributing an answer to Physics Stack Exchange!


                                                    • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                                    But avoid


                                                    • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                                    • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

                                                    Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


                                                    To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                                                    draft saved


                                                    draft discarded














                                                    StackExchange.ready(
                                                    function ()
                                                    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fphysics.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f481126%2fwhy-the-work-done-is-positive-when-bringing-2-opposite-charges-together%23new-answer', 'question_page');

                                                    );

                                                    Post as a guest















                                                    Required, but never shown





















































                                                    Required, but never shown














                                                    Required, but never shown












                                                    Required, but never shown







                                                    Required, but never shown

































                                                    Required, but never shown














                                                    Required, but never shown












                                                    Required, but never shown







                                                    Required, but never shown







                                                    Popular posts from this blog

                                                    Siegen Nawigatsjuun

                                                    Log på Navigationsmenu

                                                    Log på Navigationsmenu