How is it believable that Euron could so easily pull off this ambush?In the TV show, who cut this person's hand off?How could Craster be that confident?How could “this character” be sent to the citadelWhat conditions are allowed for a decree of legitimisation or inheritance?Does Euron have “magical” support that helped him build 1000 ships?How did Euron get so close unnoticed?How does Euron travel so fast?Why is Daenerys willing to let Iron Islanders secede but not the Northmen?Who did Cersei mean by 'silver-haired bitch'?How could this character survive this action in the Game of Thrones episode “The Long Night”?
Convert a huge txt-file into a dataset
Searching for a sentence that I only know part of it using Google's operators
What does the copyright in a dissertation protect exactly?
Why is the blank symbol not considered part of the input alphabet of a Turing machine?
HTML folder located within IOS Image file?
Is there a reason why Turkey took the Balkan territories of the Ottoman Empire, instead of Greece or another of the Balkan states?
Convert Numbers To Emoji Math
How do I give a darkroom course without negs from the attendees?
Test whether a string is in a list with variable
why it is 2>&1 and not 2>>&1 to append to a log file
Can you just subtract the challenge rating of friendly NPCs?
Why doesn't increasing the temperature of something like wood or paper set them on fire?
GitLab account hacked and repo wiped
What detail can Hubble see on Mars?
Make me a minimum magic sum
How does jetBlue determine its boarding order?
My parents are Afghan
How do I minimise waste on a flight?
Does this website provide consistent translation into Wookiee?
Drug Testing and Prescribed Medications
Why did Gendry call himself Gendry Rivers?
How to increase row height of a table and vertically "align middle"?
How to get the decimal part of a number in apex
A♭ major 9th chord in Bach is unexpectedly dissonant/jazzy
How is it believable that Euron could so easily pull off this ambush?
In the TV show, who cut this person's hand off?How could Craster be that confident?How could “this character” be sent to the citadelWhat conditions are allowed for a decree of legitimisation or inheritance?Does Euron have “magical” support that helped him build 1000 ships?How did Euron get so close unnoticed?How does Euron travel so fast?Why is Daenerys willing to let Iron Islanders secede but not the Northmen?Who did Cersei mean by 'silver-haired bitch'?How could this character survive this action in the Game of Thrones episode “The Long Night”?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
Daenerys has Varys on her side who is some kind of master spy.
She also has Bran who can scout for her easily.
She was up in the sky from where she should be able to see Euron's fleet where they were hiding before she was in range of the scorpions (if the ships could shoot at her, she should be seeing them as well).
She has a strategist Tyrion who knows about the existence of this dragon-killing weapon when Bronn attacked her during Battle of the Gold Road.
How is it believable that Euron could ambush Daenerys so easily?
game-of-thrones
New contributor
|
show 3 more comments
Daenerys has Varys on her side who is some kind of master spy.
She also has Bran who can scout for her easily.
She was up in the sky from where she should be able to see Euron's fleet where they were hiding before she was in range of the scorpions (if the ships could shoot at her, she should be seeing them as well).
She has a strategist Tyrion who knows about the existence of this dragon-killing weapon when Bronn attacked her during Battle of the Gold Road.
How is it believable that Euron could ambush Daenerys so easily?
game-of-thrones
New contributor
13
simple answer: it is not...
– Kepotx
5 hours ago
1
I KNOW, RIGHT?! ;)
– DavidW
5 hours ago
2
Several factors could be at play: they simply weren't expecting an attack by sea, Daenerys might be overconfident (she's beaten worse odds before), Varys doesn't seem to have a spy network at the moment, all Tyrion saw was a ballista fail to kill a dragon (Drogon seemed ok within minutes), and Daenerys can only see so much when flying her dragon and it seems like she doesn't typically do scouting missions.
– just_happen_to_know
5 hours ago
8
The whole episode was full of poor writing, this was just one very obvious instance of it.
– TheLethalCarrot
5 hours ago
2
She doesn't have Bran. Bran is not interested with conflicts of humans.
– atayenel
4 hours ago
|
show 3 more comments
Daenerys has Varys on her side who is some kind of master spy.
She also has Bran who can scout for her easily.
She was up in the sky from where she should be able to see Euron's fleet where they were hiding before she was in range of the scorpions (if the ships could shoot at her, she should be seeing them as well).
She has a strategist Tyrion who knows about the existence of this dragon-killing weapon when Bronn attacked her during Battle of the Gold Road.
How is it believable that Euron could ambush Daenerys so easily?
game-of-thrones
New contributor
Daenerys has Varys on her side who is some kind of master spy.
She also has Bran who can scout for her easily.
She was up in the sky from where she should be able to see Euron's fleet where they were hiding before she was in range of the scorpions (if the ships could shoot at her, she should be seeing them as well).
She has a strategist Tyrion who knows about the existence of this dragon-killing weapon when Bronn attacked her during Battle of the Gold Road.
How is it believable that Euron could ambush Daenerys so easily?
game-of-thrones
game-of-thrones
New contributor
New contributor
edited 6 hours ago
Edlothiad
55k21288299
55k21288299
New contributor
asked 6 hours ago
avmohanavmohan
1614
1614
New contributor
New contributor
13
simple answer: it is not...
– Kepotx
5 hours ago
1
I KNOW, RIGHT?! ;)
– DavidW
5 hours ago
2
Several factors could be at play: they simply weren't expecting an attack by sea, Daenerys might be overconfident (she's beaten worse odds before), Varys doesn't seem to have a spy network at the moment, all Tyrion saw was a ballista fail to kill a dragon (Drogon seemed ok within minutes), and Daenerys can only see so much when flying her dragon and it seems like she doesn't typically do scouting missions.
– just_happen_to_know
5 hours ago
8
The whole episode was full of poor writing, this was just one very obvious instance of it.
– TheLethalCarrot
5 hours ago
2
She doesn't have Bran. Bran is not interested with conflicts of humans.
– atayenel
4 hours ago
|
show 3 more comments
13
simple answer: it is not...
– Kepotx
5 hours ago
1
I KNOW, RIGHT?! ;)
– DavidW
5 hours ago
2
Several factors could be at play: they simply weren't expecting an attack by sea, Daenerys might be overconfident (she's beaten worse odds before), Varys doesn't seem to have a spy network at the moment, all Tyrion saw was a ballista fail to kill a dragon (Drogon seemed ok within minutes), and Daenerys can only see so much when flying her dragon and it seems like she doesn't typically do scouting missions.
– just_happen_to_know
5 hours ago
8
The whole episode was full of poor writing, this was just one very obvious instance of it.
– TheLethalCarrot
5 hours ago
2
She doesn't have Bran. Bran is not interested with conflicts of humans.
– atayenel
4 hours ago
13
13
simple answer: it is not...
– Kepotx
5 hours ago
simple answer: it is not...
– Kepotx
5 hours ago
1
1
I KNOW, RIGHT?! ;)
– DavidW
5 hours ago
I KNOW, RIGHT?! ;)
– DavidW
5 hours ago
2
2
Several factors could be at play: they simply weren't expecting an attack by sea, Daenerys might be overconfident (she's beaten worse odds before), Varys doesn't seem to have a spy network at the moment, all Tyrion saw was a ballista fail to kill a dragon (Drogon seemed ok within minutes), and Daenerys can only see so much when flying her dragon and it seems like she doesn't typically do scouting missions.
– just_happen_to_know
5 hours ago
Several factors could be at play: they simply weren't expecting an attack by sea, Daenerys might be overconfident (she's beaten worse odds before), Varys doesn't seem to have a spy network at the moment, all Tyrion saw was a ballista fail to kill a dragon (Drogon seemed ok within minutes), and Daenerys can only see so much when flying her dragon and it seems like she doesn't typically do scouting missions.
– just_happen_to_know
5 hours ago
8
8
The whole episode was full of poor writing, this was just one very obvious instance of it.
– TheLethalCarrot
5 hours ago
The whole episode was full of poor writing, this was just one very obvious instance of it.
– TheLethalCarrot
5 hours ago
2
2
She doesn't have Bran. Bran is not interested with conflicts of humans.
– atayenel
4 hours ago
She doesn't have Bran. Bran is not interested with conflicts of humans.
– atayenel
4 hours ago
|
show 3 more comments
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
The official answer is that Daenerys forgot about Euron and thus was easily ambushed.
Please watch the Inside the Episode for the full justification of this baffling writing.
New contributor
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
4
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
add a comment |
I think it's well established that the writing on this portion is not as well thought out as it could be. With that said, I think something of a frame challenge is warranted here because I'm not sure we should describe the ambush as being easy and I think some of your assumptions may not be fully supported by the show.
First, it didn't seem easy.
Euron, while a horrible, horrible person, has generally been portrayed as competent. He had a small fleet of ships specifically prepared for the threat they knew they were going to face, waiting in the best ambush point you could ask for, along the route he knew the other side was going to take. There was no indication of how long they were waiting there and it is entirely plausible that they had been waiting for weeks to pull off an ambush.
This doesn't strike me as being something they pulled off easily, but a competent (if evil) military leader using proper strategy to lay out a well-executed ambush at a choke-point. Perhaps Daenerys and her companions should have seen it coming and been ready, but this would have been a reasonable strategy by Euron even if they had known ahead of time. And it might have been harder for Daenerys and her group to know ahead of of time than you make it seem.
Second, Daenerys likely had fewer resources to gain this information than you suggest
I'm not sure that Daenerys had lines of information that were as good as you suggest. You suggest that Bran should have been able to scout, but he doesn't seem able to see the future and doesn't seem inclined or able to take the initiative. He also doesn't seem overly fond of Daenerys and probably would have been in Winterfell with his sister rather than travelling with the boats. In other words, Bran would only have been useful if the ambush was set up before the boats left Winterfell and someone thought to ask him in a way that convinced him to answer.
As for her flying low enough to not see them, that does seem like a tactical mistake on her part, but she is well established as making a lot of tactical mistakes. (The battle of Winterfell was filled with tactical blunders for example). Also, one of her dragons was injured. The injured one might have had a hard time gaining altitude and she didn't seem inclined to separate them. While it remains a mistake not to take the able-bodied dragon both higher and further ahead for scouting purposes, it is one that had a reason behind it.
Tyrion should have warned her about the possibility of an ambush, but a general knowledge that it is a possibility over a long journey doesn't tell you much of use. She should have been more wary, but she was established as overconfident and poor at tactics.
Varys was a skilled spymaster, but that is only useful if you have access to a network of spies and his was disrupted repeatedly.
Somewhat sloppy writing, but justifications are available.
So, yes, I think the real answer is somewhat sloppy writing (at a minimum they should have shown Tyrion providing a general warning of the possibility of an ambush), but in-universe reasons for why they could be taken by surprise do exist.
New contributor
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
add a comment |
While I may feel that it was a bit weak that she didn't notice, or at least react to Euron firing at her...
Common sense approach:
Dany: She is distracted by watching her Dragon heal after the battle, probably a bit distracted because she isn't in the North anymore and isn't second fiddle to everyone else in the North.
Everyone else: Last they heard, Euron was still in King's Landing. Vaserys' spy network is likely broken a bit, since the entirety of the North was at Winterfel for the battle, and we know it's a 2 weekish journey from KL to Winterfel.
And there is a long naval history of fleet's hiding on the farside of islands to ambush other fleets. It occurred as recently as WWII in the Pacific, and planes are as close as we will get to dragons (the A10 not withstanding).
Really everyone has their guard down. They are all tired from TBoW, Vaserys and Tyrion are extremely distracted by Dany's growing mental decline and Jon being a Targaryn. The Unsullied aren't a spy network and the small fleet they took to Dragon's Stone didn't include all of the unsullied, only a small number of the remaining. I also don't think they were ever established at being master seafarers, at least nothing close to the Ironbound.
Ultimately, by the time they got close enough to Dragon's Stone to be able to see the otherside of the island from a Dragon, it would have been too late.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
avmohan is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f211842%2fhow-is-it-believable-that-euron-could-so-easily-pull-off-this-ambush%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
The official answer is that Daenerys forgot about Euron and thus was easily ambushed.
Please watch the Inside the Episode for the full justification of this baffling writing.
New contributor
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
4
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
add a comment |
The official answer is that Daenerys forgot about Euron and thus was easily ambushed.
Please watch the Inside the Episode for the full justification of this baffling writing.
New contributor
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
4
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
add a comment |
The official answer is that Daenerys forgot about Euron and thus was easily ambushed.
Please watch the Inside the Episode for the full justification of this baffling writing.
New contributor
The official answer is that Daenerys forgot about Euron and thus was easily ambushed.
Please watch the Inside the Episode for the full justification of this baffling writing.
New contributor
New contributor
answered 4 hours ago
JanuaryJanuary
803
803
New contributor
New contributor
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
4
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
add a comment |
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
4
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
Hi there. That sounds like an interesting find! I strongly suggest you edit your answer to include some more quotes (as you hint towards a "full justification"); that will make for a better answer as all the info will be gathered in one place.
– Jenayah
4 hours ago
4
4
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
yeah, she forgot about the fleet that thwarted her by surprise not once (dorne & other greyjoy), not twice (casterly rock), but three times (snuck away to get golden company). I know it's the "inside the rpisode" answer, but come on... they literally mentioned the greyjoy fleet at the beginning of the ep.
– KillianDS
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
@KillianDS Did you know that D&D not content with ruining the show, have DIRECTED the last episode?
– January
3 hours ago
add a comment |
I think it's well established that the writing on this portion is not as well thought out as it could be. With that said, I think something of a frame challenge is warranted here because I'm not sure we should describe the ambush as being easy and I think some of your assumptions may not be fully supported by the show.
First, it didn't seem easy.
Euron, while a horrible, horrible person, has generally been portrayed as competent. He had a small fleet of ships specifically prepared for the threat they knew they were going to face, waiting in the best ambush point you could ask for, along the route he knew the other side was going to take. There was no indication of how long they were waiting there and it is entirely plausible that they had been waiting for weeks to pull off an ambush.
This doesn't strike me as being something they pulled off easily, but a competent (if evil) military leader using proper strategy to lay out a well-executed ambush at a choke-point. Perhaps Daenerys and her companions should have seen it coming and been ready, but this would have been a reasonable strategy by Euron even if they had known ahead of time. And it might have been harder for Daenerys and her group to know ahead of of time than you make it seem.
Second, Daenerys likely had fewer resources to gain this information than you suggest
I'm not sure that Daenerys had lines of information that were as good as you suggest. You suggest that Bran should have been able to scout, but he doesn't seem able to see the future and doesn't seem inclined or able to take the initiative. He also doesn't seem overly fond of Daenerys and probably would have been in Winterfell with his sister rather than travelling with the boats. In other words, Bran would only have been useful if the ambush was set up before the boats left Winterfell and someone thought to ask him in a way that convinced him to answer.
As for her flying low enough to not see them, that does seem like a tactical mistake on her part, but she is well established as making a lot of tactical mistakes. (The battle of Winterfell was filled with tactical blunders for example). Also, one of her dragons was injured. The injured one might have had a hard time gaining altitude and she didn't seem inclined to separate them. While it remains a mistake not to take the able-bodied dragon both higher and further ahead for scouting purposes, it is one that had a reason behind it.
Tyrion should have warned her about the possibility of an ambush, but a general knowledge that it is a possibility over a long journey doesn't tell you much of use. She should have been more wary, but she was established as overconfident and poor at tactics.
Varys was a skilled spymaster, but that is only useful if you have access to a network of spies and his was disrupted repeatedly.
Somewhat sloppy writing, but justifications are available.
So, yes, I think the real answer is somewhat sloppy writing (at a minimum they should have shown Tyrion providing a general warning of the possibility of an ambush), but in-universe reasons for why they could be taken by surprise do exist.
New contributor
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
add a comment |
I think it's well established that the writing on this portion is not as well thought out as it could be. With that said, I think something of a frame challenge is warranted here because I'm not sure we should describe the ambush as being easy and I think some of your assumptions may not be fully supported by the show.
First, it didn't seem easy.
Euron, while a horrible, horrible person, has generally been portrayed as competent. He had a small fleet of ships specifically prepared for the threat they knew they were going to face, waiting in the best ambush point you could ask for, along the route he knew the other side was going to take. There was no indication of how long they were waiting there and it is entirely plausible that they had been waiting for weeks to pull off an ambush.
This doesn't strike me as being something they pulled off easily, but a competent (if evil) military leader using proper strategy to lay out a well-executed ambush at a choke-point. Perhaps Daenerys and her companions should have seen it coming and been ready, but this would have been a reasonable strategy by Euron even if they had known ahead of time. And it might have been harder for Daenerys and her group to know ahead of of time than you make it seem.
Second, Daenerys likely had fewer resources to gain this information than you suggest
I'm not sure that Daenerys had lines of information that were as good as you suggest. You suggest that Bran should have been able to scout, but he doesn't seem able to see the future and doesn't seem inclined or able to take the initiative. He also doesn't seem overly fond of Daenerys and probably would have been in Winterfell with his sister rather than travelling with the boats. In other words, Bran would only have been useful if the ambush was set up before the boats left Winterfell and someone thought to ask him in a way that convinced him to answer.
As for her flying low enough to not see them, that does seem like a tactical mistake on her part, but she is well established as making a lot of tactical mistakes. (The battle of Winterfell was filled with tactical blunders for example). Also, one of her dragons was injured. The injured one might have had a hard time gaining altitude and she didn't seem inclined to separate them. While it remains a mistake not to take the able-bodied dragon both higher and further ahead for scouting purposes, it is one that had a reason behind it.
Tyrion should have warned her about the possibility of an ambush, but a general knowledge that it is a possibility over a long journey doesn't tell you much of use. She should have been more wary, but she was established as overconfident and poor at tactics.
Varys was a skilled spymaster, but that is only useful if you have access to a network of spies and his was disrupted repeatedly.
Somewhat sloppy writing, but justifications are available.
So, yes, I think the real answer is somewhat sloppy writing (at a minimum they should have shown Tyrion providing a general warning of the possibility of an ambush), but in-universe reasons for why they could be taken by surprise do exist.
New contributor
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
add a comment |
I think it's well established that the writing on this portion is not as well thought out as it could be. With that said, I think something of a frame challenge is warranted here because I'm not sure we should describe the ambush as being easy and I think some of your assumptions may not be fully supported by the show.
First, it didn't seem easy.
Euron, while a horrible, horrible person, has generally been portrayed as competent. He had a small fleet of ships specifically prepared for the threat they knew they were going to face, waiting in the best ambush point you could ask for, along the route he knew the other side was going to take. There was no indication of how long they were waiting there and it is entirely plausible that they had been waiting for weeks to pull off an ambush.
This doesn't strike me as being something they pulled off easily, but a competent (if evil) military leader using proper strategy to lay out a well-executed ambush at a choke-point. Perhaps Daenerys and her companions should have seen it coming and been ready, but this would have been a reasonable strategy by Euron even if they had known ahead of time. And it might have been harder for Daenerys and her group to know ahead of of time than you make it seem.
Second, Daenerys likely had fewer resources to gain this information than you suggest
I'm not sure that Daenerys had lines of information that were as good as you suggest. You suggest that Bran should have been able to scout, but he doesn't seem able to see the future and doesn't seem inclined or able to take the initiative. He also doesn't seem overly fond of Daenerys and probably would have been in Winterfell with his sister rather than travelling with the boats. In other words, Bran would only have been useful if the ambush was set up before the boats left Winterfell and someone thought to ask him in a way that convinced him to answer.
As for her flying low enough to not see them, that does seem like a tactical mistake on her part, but she is well established as making a lot of tactical mistakes. (The battle of Winterfell was filled with tactical blunders for example). Also, one of her dragons was injured. The injured one might have had a hard time gaining altitude and she didn't seem inclined to separate them. While it remains a mistake not to take the able-bodied dragon both higher and further ahead for scouting purposes, it is one that had a reason behind it.
Tyrion should have warned her about the possibility of an ambush, but a general knowledge that it is a possibility over a long journey doesn't tell you much of use. She should have been more wary, but she was established as overconfident and poor at tactics.
Varys was a skilled spymaster, but that is only useful if you have access to a network of spies and his was disrupted repeatedly.
Somewhat sloppy writing, but justifications are available.
So, yes, I think the real answer is somewhat sloppy writing (at a minimum they should have shown Tyrion providing a general warning of the possibility of an ambush), but in-universe reasons for why they could be taken by surprise do exist.
New contributor
I think it's well established that the writing on this portion is not as well thought out as it could be. With that said, I think something of a frame challenge is warranted here because I'm not sure we should describe the ambush as being easy and I think some of your assumptions may not be fully supported by the show.
First, it didn't seem easy.
Euron, while a horrible, horrible person, has generally been portrayed as competent. He had a small fleet of ships specifically prepared for the threat they knew they were going to face, waiting in the best ambush point you could ask for, along the route he knew the other side was going to take. There was no indication of how long they were waiting there and it is entirely plausible that they had been waiting for weeks to pull off an ambush.
This doesn't strike me as being something they pulled off easily, but a competent (if evil) military leader using proper strategy to lay out a well-executed ambush at a choke-point. Perhaps Daenerys and her companions should have seen it coming and been ready, but this would have been a reasonable strategy by Euron even if they had known ahead of time. And it might have been harder for Daenerys and her group to know ahead of of time than you make it seem.
Second, Daenerys likely had fewer resources to gain this information than you suggest
I'm not sure that Daenerys had lines of information that were as good as you suggest. You suggest that Bran should have been able to scout, but he doesn't seem able to see the future and doesn't seem inclined or able to take the initiative. He also doesn't seem overly fond of Daenerys and probably would have been in Winterfell with his sister rather than travelling with the boats. In other words, Bran would only have been useful if the ambush was set up before the boats left Winterfell and someone thought to ask him in a way that convinced him to answer.
As for her flying low enough to not see them, that does seem like a tactical mistake on her part, but she is well established as making a lot of tactical mistakes. (The battle of Winterfell was filled with tactical blunders for example). Also, one of her dragons was injured. The injured one might have had a hard time gaining altitude and she didn't seem inclined to separate them. While it remains a mistake not to take the able-bodied dragon both higher and further ahead for scouting purposes, it is one that had a reason behind it.
Tyrion should have warned her about the possibility of an ambush, but a general knowledge that it is a possibility over a long journey doesn't tell you much of use. She should have been more wary, but she was established as overconfident and poor at tactics.
Varys was a skilled spymaster, but that is only useful if you have access to a network of spies and his was disrupted repeatedly.
Somewhat sloppy writing, but justifications are available.
So, yes, I think the real answer is somewhat sloppy writing (at a minimum they should have shown Tyrion providing a general warning of the possibility of an ambush), but in-universe reasons for why they could be taken by surprise do exist.
New contributor
edited 2 hours ago
New contributor
answered 2 hours ago
TimothyAWisemanTimothyAWiseman
1314
1314
New contributor
New contributor
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
add a comment |
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
@Jenayah Thanks.
– TimothyAWiseman
2 hours ago
add a comment |
While I may feel that it was a bit weak that she didn't notice, or at least react to Euron firing at her...
Common sense approach:
Dany: She is distracted by watching her Dragon heal after the battle, probably a bit distracted because she isn't in the North anymore and isn't second fiddle to everyone else in the North.
Everyone else: Last they heard, Euron was still in King's Landing. Vaserys' spy network is likely broken a bit, since the entirety of the North was at Winterfel for the battle, and we know it's a 2 weekish journey from KL to Winterfel.
And there is a long naval history of fleet's hiding on the farside of islands to ambush other fleets. It occurred as recently as WWII in the Pacific, and planes are as close as we will get to dragons (the A10 not withstanding).
Really everyone has their guard down. They are all tired from TBoW, Vaserys and Tyrion are extremely distracted by Dany's growing mental decline and Jon being a Targaryn. The Unsullied aren't a spy network and the small fleet they took to Dragon's Stone didn't include all of the unsullied, only a small number of the remaining. I also don't think they were ever established at being master seafarers, at least nothing close to the Ironbound.
Ultimately, by the time they got close enough to Dragon's Stone to be able to see the otherside of the island from a Dragon, it would have been too late.
add a comment |
While I may feel that it was a bit weak that she didn't notice, or at least react to Euron firing at her...
Common sense approach:
Dany: She is distracted by watching her Dragon heal after the battle, probably a bit distracted because she isn't in the North anymore and isn't second fiddle to everyone else in the North.
Everyone else: Last they heard, Euron was still in King's Landing. Vaserys' spy network is likely broken a bit, since the entirety of the North was at Winterfel for the battle, and we know it's a 2 weekish journey from KL to Winterfel.
And there is a long naval history of fleet's hiding on the farside of islands to ambush other fleets. It occurred as recently as WWII in the Pacific, and planes are as close as we will get to dragons (the A10 not withstanding).
Really everyone has their guard down. They are all tired from TBoW, Vaserys and Tyrion are extremely distracted by Dany's growing mental decline and Jon being a Targaryn. The Unsullied aren't a spy network and the small fleet they took to Dragon's Stone didn't include all of the unsullied, only a small number of the remaining. I also don't think they were ever established at being master seafarers, at least nothing close to the Ironbound.
Ultimately, by the time they got close enough to Dragon's Stone to be able to see the otherside of the island from a Dragon, it would have been too late.
add a comment |
While I may feel that it was a bit weak that she didn't notice, or at least react to Euron firing at her...
Common sense approach:
Dany: She is distracted by watching her Dragon heal after the battle, probably a bit distracted because she isn't in the North anymore and isn't second fiddle to everyone else in the North.
Everyone else: Last they heard, Euron was still in King's Landing. Vaserys' spy network is likely broken a bit, since the entirety of the North was at Winterfel for the battle, and we know it's a 2 weekish journey from KL to Winterfel.
And there is a long naval history of fleet's hiding on the farside of islands to ambush other fleets. It occurred as recently as WWII in the Pacific, and planes are as close as we will get to dragons (the A10 not withstanding).
Really everyone has their guard down. They are all tired from TBoW, Vaserys and Tyrion are extremely distracted by Dany's growing mental decline and Jon being a Targaryn. The Unsullied aren't a spy network and the small fleet they took to Dragon's Stone didn't include all of the unsullied, only a small number of the remaining. I also don't think they were ever established at being master seafarers, at least nothing close to the Ironbound.
Ultimately, by the time they got close enough to Dragon's Stone to be able to see the otherside of the island from a Dragon, it would have been too late.
While I may feel that it was a bit weak that she didn't notice, or at least react to Euron firing at her...
Common sense approach:
Dany: She is distracted by watching her Dragon heal after the battle, probably a bit distracted because she isn't in the North anymore and isn't second fiddle to everyone else in the North.
Everyone else: Last they heard, Euron was still in King's Landing. Vaserys' spy network is likely broken a bit, since the entirety of the North was at Winterfel for the battle, and we know it's a 2 weekish journey from KL to Winterfel.
And there is a long naval history of fleet's hiding on the farside of islands to ambush other fleets. It occurred as recently as WWII in the Pacific, and planes are as close as we will get to dragons (the A10 not withstanding).
Really everyone has their guard down. They are all tired from TBoW, Vaserys and Tyrion are extremely distracted by Dany's growing mental decline and Jon being a Targaryn. The Unsullied aren't a spy network and the small fleet they took to Dragon's Stone didn't include all of the unsullied, only a small number of the remaining. I also don't think they were ever established at being master seafarers, at least nothing close to the Ironbound.
Ultimately, by the time they got close enough to Dragon's Stone to be able to see the otherside of the island from a Dragon, it would have been too late.
answered 3 hours ago
McFuuMcFuu
1,0301010
1,0301010
add a comment |
add a comment |
avmohan is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
avmohan is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
avmohan is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
avmohan is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f211842%2fhow-is-it-believable-that-euron-could-so-easily-pull-off-this-ambush%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
13
simple answer: it is not...
– Kepotx
5 hours ago
1
I KNOW, RIGHT?! ;)
– DavidW
5 hours ago
2
Several factors could be at play: they simply weren't expecting an attack by sea, Daenerys might be overconfident (she's beaten worse odds before), Varys doesn't seem to have a spy network at the moment, all Tyrion saw was a ballista fail to kill a dragon (Drogon seemed ok within minutes), and Daenerys can only see so much when flying her dragon and it seems like she doesn't typically do scouting missions.
– just_happen_to_know
5 hours ago
8
The whole episode was full of poor writing, this was just one very obvious instance of it.
– TheLethalCarrot
5 hours ago
2
She doesn't have Bran. Bran is not interested with conflicts of humans.
– atayenel
4 hours ago